Human Labor Alternative

Ironback.ai vs. Managed VA Company

Managed VA companies provide offshore human workers for admin tasks. AI Staff builds automated systems that handle the same tasks 24/7 without per-hour billing. The right choice depends on whether your problem needs human judgment or just consistent execution.

✓ Where Ironback.ai Wins

  • Available 24/7 with no overtime, no sick days, no turnover
  • Scales to handle volume spikes without adding headcount
  • Costs less over 12 months for high-volume repetitive tasks
  • Brings benchmark data from 20+ similar businesses in your industry
  • Implementation includes proprietary ROI analysis — not just task fulfillment

Where Managed VA Company May Win

  • Better for tasks requiring genuine human judgment (creative work, complex negotiations, nuanced client situations)
  • No setup time — VAs start with existing skills
  • Easier to adjust task scope without reconfiguration

Best fit: Ironback.ai

Owner-operated service businesses where the main bottleneck is high-volume, repeatable processes (scheduling, follow-up, invoicing, reminders) that must run 24/7 and consistently every time.

Best fit: Managed VA Company

Businesses that need flexible human assistance for varied, judgment-heavy tasks that change frequently — executive support, creative work, complex customer service.

Real Cost Comparison

Year-one total cost of ownership — including setup, ongoing fees, and hidden management costs.

Ironback.ai

$7,500 assessment + $3,500–5,500/month implementation + $2,500–3,500/month ongoing

Managed VA Company

$8–25/hour × 160 hours/month = $1,280–4,000/month for one VA; enterprise VA agencies charge $3,000–8,000/month for a team

Year-One TCO Summary

AI Staff: $49,500–85,500. VA company: $15,000–96,000 depending on hours, plus management overhead. After month 6, AI Staff cost stays flat while VA costs grow with volume.

Common Questions

Do VAs understand my industry better than AI?

VAs are trained on your processes. AI Staff is configured with deep vertical knowledge of your industry's specific workflows, software, and terminology — plus cross-client data from similar businesses.

What happens when a VA leaves?

VA turnover means retraining, transition time, and knowledge loss. AI systems don't leave. Once configured, the system runs with the same consistency until you change it.

Can I start with a VA and move to AI later?

Yes — many clients start with a VA to handle gaps while we build the automation infrastructure. The goal is to automate everything that doesn't require human judgment, freeing any VAs or staff for higher-value work.

See if Ironback.ai is the right fit for your business

Book a free 30-minute call. We'll ask about your situation and give you an honest answer — including if a different approach would serve you better.